Sex designation vs. preferred gender identity

By Jillian Page
LGBT Perspectives editor

QUEBEC — Sometimes transgenderism confuses the heck out of me — both as a journalist and as an LGBT advocate. And I know I’m not the only one who is unclear on some of the concepts.

Take a recent report out of Nova Scotia as an example. This week, several media outlets ran the same Canadian Press report announcing that trans people are now permitted to change the designation on their birth certificates with “a self-declaration and a letter of support from professionals such as a nurse practitioner, physician or social worker.”

But what designation exactly are trans people allowed to change on said certificates?

That’s where the confusion in the media lies, it seems.

The majority of the media reports say trans people in Nova Scotia are now allowed to change their “sex” designation.

But the CBC rewrote the lede of the Canadian Press article to say that trans people can now “identify their preferred gender on their birth certificates.” The CBC even went with the word “gender” in its headline while CTV and others went with “sex designation.

See the difference?  Who’s right, and who’s wrong?

Well, technically, they are all right.

Trans people are now allowed to change the sex designation on their birth certificates, because that is the only option available on those particular forms: “Sex: F.”  Not: “Gender: F.”

But CBC went to great lengths — i.e. changed the CP article — to point out that trans people are, in fact, allowed to “identify their preferred gender on their birth certificates.” In other words, trans people do not have to physically change their sex to identify as their preferred gender . . .

Hmm. if journalists are confused about all of this, what about the general population who might be reading these articles?

Well, as at least one reader commenting  on the CBC article points out, there is a difference between sex and gender.

Monash University’s site puts it this way:

Sex refers to biological differences; chromosomes, hormonal profiles, internal and external sex organs.”

Gender describes the characteristics that a society or culture delineates as masculine or feminine.”

So, it used to be that a person could legally change sex designation if he or she made biological changes. For example, a MtF person had to do as much as possible to make her body biologically female through HRT and sexual reassignment surgery, along with psychological counselling.

It was pretty straightforward.

Today, it’s not so straightforward. People can change their birth certificates to reflect their preferred gender — even if no biological changes have been made. But what is actually being changed on the certificate is the sex designation.

Hence the confusion over terminology in the media, and in society in general.

I suspect that society will have to rethink birth certificates altogether.  Some have even suggested dropping sex designation from those forms, but that is unlikely to happen. And besides, many trans people desperately want a “Sex: F” designation on their birth certificates — I doubt they would support a certificate with no sex designation at all.

For now, though, we will continue to live in a world in which the line between “sex designation” and “preferred gender identity” is blurred, and where they will mean the same thing at times, and not the same thing at other times. And where journalists may get it wrong sometimes.

Comments?

****

“Let harmlessness be the keynote of your life.” — Alice Bailey

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Sex designation vs. preferred gender identity”

  1. As a post opp trans woman has always found it easy sex = if you had grs then you’re sex is female if you have not had grs an still have a penis= male mabe need a inter sex classification on I’d gender is who u chose to be sex is working u are blur line thier

    Like

  2. Here in Ontario you can change your BC even if you have not undergone gender surgery but you have to be born in Ontario. When I found out about this I went and had mine legally changed on both the long and short form. I was sick of people asking for my ID and seeing male when they clearly saw with their eyes standing Infront of them female. It’s about time other places let trans people change their BC to the gender they feel they are.

    I’m sure in the coming years gender won’t be such a huge thing as it is right now and this conversation about BC and what not will be a thing of the past and maybe they will just remove gender all together. But and till that happens people still want to be known as one or the other. It helps people fit in I think.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I recently changed the sex on my birth certificate, though I actually wanted to leave it as it was. The reason is that the only choices for sex were male and female, and I felt that the most honest answer would b “intersex,” “transgender” or even “other.” I am convinced that I occupy the blurry space between transsexual and intersex, but that for me, I am best expressed, most myself when expressed as a woman. So since most people (and most US laws) conflate gender and sex, I changed my marker to “Female” so as to minimize the possibility that I could be denied my authentic personhood because my BC said “Male.” It’s a tricky thing because I am not a natal female, nor am I really a natal male: I was born trans.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s